Editorial: Save The Tam News
The district’s proposed cuts would eliminate the print edition and crater the publication’s quality.
Mar 8, 2020
Due to the failure of parcel tax Measure B, our school district will have to make $16.8 million in cuts, including $3 million before the end of this school year. On March 10, the board of trustees will vote on a series of proposed cuts. One of them is to save around $100k by capping the Advanced Journalism class and cutting the adviser release period.
Not only will the lack of support for our curriculum and our advisors immensely lower our quality of education after these cuts, but the student journalists in our community will soon be virtually nonexistent. Losing the journalism release period means likely losing The Tam News, The Redwood Bark, and The Jolly Roger.
Of the cuts on the board agenda this Tuesday, one is to “suspend journalism release periods at all three comprehensive sites.” Our release period, also known as pasteup, is our allotted time to create the magazine, and the chance for our adviser to edit articles from our 150 staff members. Without that time, there will be no print publication. Online quality will plummet, as the journalism adviser will not be compensated for the 20-plus hours of overtime we all put in at school monthly.
Also proposed for Tuesday’s meeting is capping student enrollment in electives and changing the choice to a lottery or waitlist system. This cap will block students who have completed the Nonfiction course from joining Advanced Journalism and bar returning students from entering as well. By decreasing enrollment, we are inevitably damaging our publication.
All of the proposed cuts will be incredible losses for the district. But by dismissing our publications, we are destroying student journalism. Freedom of the press is being threatened nationally and globally; it doesn’t bode well for our community to end our support of journalism locally. The only other release period under threat is the Global Studies program; no other on-campus periods are in question (i.e. leadership and drama).
In exchange for a savings of $30,000, about one third of one percent of the district’s annual budget, we are losing a 100-year-old magazine that ranks in the top 20 nationally, according to the Columbia Scholastic Press Association. We are losing our in-depth coverage of the Marin City raid, where, unlike other local publications, we had the most representation of students’ voices impacted by the event. We are losing our news piece and coinciding editorial on the recent lockdown, which provided a unique perspective that other coverage lacked, revealing our school’s failings under the stress of that event. We are losing our feature that unveiled the inequity of the district’s maternity leave policy. We are losing our editorial on the scavenger hunt, which won first place as the best student editorial in the entire country from the Columbia Scholastic Press Association. We are losing countless awards and we are losing our name. We are losing our staff members. We are losing our chance to serve the community and make an impact.
Stand with us. Come to the board meeting — 6 p.m. at Redwood this Tuesday — or write to the board to voice your support. Don’t let this be the end of The Tam News.
J. M. Thomas ♦ Mar 21, 2020 at 3:45 am
Aloha from Kauai and best wishes for health and recovery!
I was editor-in-chief of the Tam News during the 1976-1977 school year. This was my senior year when our faculty advisor, Dick Fregulia, decided to take a year’s sabbatical. This effectively left me “in charge” not only of the paper’s editing and publication, but also “in charge“ of the grading of students enrolled in the Tam News journalism class! Mr. Klein, who passed away not long ago, was our replacement faculty adviser, if in name only.
Soon after I was re-elected editor in January 1977, the TUHSD sprang on me much of what you are now faced with: the District proposed “outsourcing” the three District papers as essentially independent business operations. This would have required the student newspapers at Tam, Redwood, and Drake to sell advertising in order to finance the operations of
the three student newspapers.
I did not have a degree in business, the time, energy, and wherewithal to comply with this proposal. It was all I could do to produce the paper as I expected to do, to complete my senior year course work, and to apply to colleges: Stanford, Harvard, and UC Davis.
I met with the other District HS editors, and I organized a “resistance movement” to secure student signatures on a petition drive in support of continuing TUHSD financing for the three student newspapers. The student response to this campaign was overwhelming. I also published some rather heated editorials encouraging student support to our cause.
The signed petitions were presented to the TUHSD Board at a Board meeting. The Board got the message that opposition to its proposal was overwhelming and backed down by withdrawing its proposal.
I feel as though I saved the Tam News then by organizing this effort when otherwise there would not have been any other organized effort. This was confirmed at the time by student board member, John Sylla, who was a nonvoting board member. John was able to give me the inside lowdown. John went on to Harvard and to the University of Chicago.
You, too, can organize a similar movement to oppose what you are facing today. It will take an effort and a commitment on your part, if that is important enough for you. There is a precedent that achieved the success that I have spelled out for you.
Keep me posted if I’m going to have to make a couple of phone calls.
Best wishes,
J. M. Thomas
Editor-in-Chief, Tam News 1976-1977
Bryan Thomas ♦ Mar 12, 2020 at 7:30 am
Anyway we can donate to specifically support the paper? A lot of alumni would be eager to support.
Kevin Mirsky ♦ Mar 10, 2020 at 2:02 pm
This is worth fighting for! Count me in.
Kevin Mirsky
Former Editor
Class ‘85
Brian Murphy ♦ Mar 10, 2020 at 1:59 pm
Journalism is critical to a free society. The Tam News, Redwood Bark and Jolly Roger are some of the most important aspects of each HS. Do everything you can to preserve them!
Riva Nelson ♦ Mar 10, 2020 at 10:52 am
I’m a ‘65 grad and my son is a 2006 grad. Tam News has always been a vital and primary source for educating young writers, thinkers and active and invested members of both the Tam community and the wider community at large. The high school paper is fundamental to the structure of a solid, high school curriculum, not just for those students who participate in the paper itself, but for all the students who read and learn from the content. I strongly urge you to do anything possible to ensure the survival of the Tam News and any other high school papers currently at risk.
Thank you,
Riva Nelson PhD
Amy Cifarelli ♦ Mar 9, 2020 at 3:14 pm
Keep the high school newspapers please…they are needed to grow future journalists as well as share knowledge with and spark communication within the student communities. Curiosity makes life more interesting!
Diana Glocker ♦ Mar 9, 2020 at 11:53 am
Must save! See you Tuesday at meeting!